Trigger warning: This post contains descriptions of non-consensual acts, and attempts of sexual assault. Including vocabulary. If this type of thing triggers you, you are advised to skip this post.
—
I see a lot of people calling out themes of the story as controversial, and that Naoko Takeuchi kept them there, even though she could have dismissed them.
Namely, non-consensual kissing all over the place, including an incestuous one.
Let’s take things from the start and say that this is a fictional work, and not reality, therefore elements that are an absolute no no in real life, can work as plot tools, or character development in a fictional story. If some readers are unable to recognize the purpose of those, while others have no issue at all, then it’s up to those readers and their ability to comprehend. This also has to do with how familiar are those readers with short stories.
You see a short story is harder to comprehend mostly because where a long story explains a scene in three pages, the short story does it in ten lines. That means the reader has to be observant, because many things are not explained but only implied.
With this out of the way, let’s talk about the controversy
Mamoru kissing a sleeping Usagi
people have gone as far as to call that “rape” …
Don’t get me wrong consent is ABSOLUTE, in real life! But this is a work of fiction.
And no it doesn’t give the wrong message to little kids, simply because Luna bursts in and calls him out for kissing Usagi, a.k.a: painting the action in a bad light.
You know what would have been “normalizing” the non-consensual? Luna standing by daydreaming of “oh how romantic” it is. But that’s not the case.
And since we are talking about fiction, intentions matter way more than in real life. He likes her, loves her even, he doesn’t have bad intentions, as a character he’s not a bad person, and we as readers/viewers know that.
In real life, yes it’s super creepy, in fiction not so much, because it’s fiction!
And in that sense Usagi kissing Mamoru without consent few episodes later is not a big deal either, because it’s fiction!
Now these two kisses, even though not consensual they still have as base mutual attraction. The kisses that follow are of a different kind.
Naoko all through out her story, has been using “forced love” (and I use the word love very lightly here, and in the way Prince Demando has used it), and kissing, as intimidation.
First you have Queen Beryl who wants to force her love into Endymion.
Then you have Prince Demando, and his forceful nature in general, he kisses Usagi in Crystal, and he goes as far as attempting rape in the manga AND the recent musicals. (yes you actually experience a live action scene of Demando trying to rape Usagi)
His explanation to all these is that “forced love” is a type of love too, and that he is not wrong for feelings it.
Then you have Black Lady kissing brainwashed Mamoru. This skyrockets the creepy, since Mamoru is her father.
Does the story paint both as something nice? Definitely not, on the contrary, you have Usagi screaming and yelling that this is not a way to love. She uses “you lost control” to Black Lady, and straight out screams to Demando that “people are not objects!”
The story pretty much shows that “evil people do evil things” “brainwashed people do evil things” “good people, do not see those as good things” “good people fight to right those wrongs”
The overall message is extremely positive and it paints good as good and evil as evil.
On top of that, through these scenes both Prince Demando and Black Lady are fleshed out as characters. They are both manipulated and brainwashed. In the case of Demando he doesn’t get a redemption story. On the other hand Black Lady does, but not without consequences. She pays the price of her wrong doings with the loss of her only friend, and not only that but that loss is caused by her. Returning to being good, Chibiusa is rewarded with new powers and the awakening of her mom.
So why should these scenes be excluded?
With that out of the way, we get to the final kiss so far which is the one Uranus gave to Sailor Moon.
And the “I have no idea how to read a scene” is big in this one.
At the beginning of the episode Haruka and Michiru have a talk about what are the measures they have to take to save the world, they understand that some of those are unethical. The inners are in their way though and they have to paint a picture of themselves as pure evil, so in their mind their actions can be justifiable.
When Haruka meets Usagi at the arcade, the inners tell her that she should stay away from her, that means the inners are already convinced that Haruka and Michiru are bad news. Haruka also plays with the moment and tells Usagi that fighting games are dangerous.
When Sailor Moon doesn’t give up and chases after Uranus, the latter needs extreme measures to convince Usagi to stay away. She says that it is dangerous to play fighting games, and she gives her a (non-consensual) kiss to convey the point, that she is indeed dangerous and she should stay away like her friends told her.
The kiss is not romantic, and its only use is to serve as intimidation.
It works for a moment because Usagi has feelings therefore she is occupied with something else. Usagi has shown attraction towards Haruka for the very first moment she met her. (the same with all her guardians).
Do I find the kiss romantic or good? No and no, I do see why it’s there though. Haruka, for Usagi, is all the barriers she has to break to be free.
What is important is that in a later episode, both Haruka and Michiru seem distressed and embarrassed of their doings, they also ask for the Princess to forgive them. So they recognize their actions as wrong doings, and as a part of their overall plan.
Fiction is not just happy things, flowers, and butterflies. Sailor Moon was never intended to be one either. From the beginning to the end the story of Sailor Moon had a dark vibe to it. From the destruction and war themes of Silver Millennium, to failed Utopias, to abusive parents, and the abuse of science, to outcasts going berserk, to manipulation of power.
I mean to me, Hotaru’s story is way more controversial than Mamoru pecking Usagi’s lips while she is napping.
Hotaru is literally kept to life, turned into a cyborg, and a vessel for an evil entity by her own father who didn’t give a damn about her as long as his plan was successful. She didn’t consent to any of this, in fact she didn’t even know what was wrong with her body. She was in extreme pain and suffering because of her father, but hey let’s focus on how kissing equals rape. (extreme sarcasm here)
By the way, when you do that equation, I just mentioned, you help rape culture thrive, because you make rape sound like nothing.
Words have power, and when you use them irresponsibly you only harm the cause you are trying to support.